So, you’ve been in a car accident. The dust has settled, but now the hard part begins—choosing the right car accident lawyer to represent you. It’s a big decision, and let’s be honest, it can feel overwhelming. But here’s the good news: You don’t have to go into that first consultation blindly. Knowing what to ask a car accident lawyer can save you from future headaches and help you find someone who will genuinely fight for your best interests.
In this blog, we’re not just listing basic questions—we’re giving you the why behind each one, so you can walk into that meeting feeling confident, informed, and ready to take control of your case.
1. How many car accident cases like mine have you handled?
You want someone who doesn’t just dabble in personal injury law—you want a lawyer who knows car accidents inside and out. Asking this question gives you insight into their real-world experience. If they’ve handled cases involving rear-end collisions, distracted driving, or uninsured motorists, they’ll know how to evaluate the details of your case.
2. What’s your approach to negotiating with insurance companies?
You should know that insurance companies are not your friends. Their job is to pay out as little as possible. That’s why it’s critical to ask how your lawyer approaches negotiations. Do they play hardball? Are they known for pushing back on lowball offers? A strong negotiator can make a big difference in your final settlement.
3. Will I be dealing with you directly, or mostly your team?
This is one of the most underrated but important questions. Some firms pass clients off to paralegals or junior associates. That’s not always a bad thing—but you deserve to know who will be answering your calls and guiding your case.
4. What do you charge, and how are fees structured?
Most personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning they only get paid if you win. But the percentage can vary, and there may be additional costs. When you’re asking what to ask a car accident lawyer, never skip over the money talk. Clear communication about fees prevents surprises down the road.
5. What’s your success rate with car accident claims?
It’s not just about how many cases a lawyer has taken—it’s about how many they’ve won or settled favorably. A solid track record shows they can deliver results, not just promises.
6. How long do you think my case will take?
No lawyer can predict the future, but experienced ones can give you a realistic timeline based on your circumstances. This helps you set expectations and plan ahead, especially if you’re dealing with medical bills or missed work.
7. What challenges do you foresee with my case?
A good car accident lawyer in Libertyville won’t sugarcoat the truth. They’ll be honest about the obstacles—whether it’s proving liability, dealing with difficult insurance adjusters, or gaps in your medical records. This kind of transparency is invaluable.
8. Have you taken car accident cases to trial?
Most cases settle out of court, but you still want someone who’s not afraid to go to trial if needed. Insurance companies know which car accident lawyers will take a case the distance—and they tend to offer better settlements to those who will.
9. How will you keep me updated on my case?
Communication can make or break your experience with a car accident or personal injury attorney in Libertyville. Ask about updates: Will they email, call, or use a client portal? And how often? You want to feel in the loop, not left in the dark.
10. Why should I choose you over another lawyer?
This question puts the lawyer on the spot—in a good way. It’s your chance to hear their pitch, understand their passion, and see how they view your case. If you’re talking to someone with the level of experience and reputation of The Law Offices of John M. Borcia, you’ll notice the difference right away.
Final Thoughts
Knowing what to ask a car accident lawyer before hiring them can make all the difference in how your case is handled—and how much compensation you ultimately receive. This isn’t just about checking boxes. It’s about finding someone who communicates well, fights hard, and knows how to win.
You don’t have to settle for the first name you Google. Do your homework, ask the tough questions, and make sure you’re putting your case in the hands of someone who truly has your back. Lawyers like those at The Law Offices of John M. Borcia have built a reputation for being just that kind of advocate—experienced, transparent, and committed to their clients.
So, when you’re wondering what to ask a car accident lawyer, start here. These questions won’t just help you hire a lawyer—they’ll help you hire the right one.
Contact a Chicago area personal injury lawyer
If you or a family member have suffered an injury due to someone else, call the Law Offices of John Borcia to speak with an experienced lawyer about your case. We have the expertise to help obtain financial compensation for the pain and suffering you or a loved one has gone through. For your convenience, our attorneys are available during the day, in the evening and on week-ends. You won't be charged unless you receive a settlement. Call (630) 302-4352 today or fill out our online contact form to email us for a free consultation.
Contact Us For a Free Consultation
Telephone: (630) 302-4352
Fax: (847) 566-6647
Email: [email protected]